WeHo Gay Couple Were Victims of Homophobic Assault Near Key West

Jeff Pellissier and Keith Miller, a newly married West Hollywood couple, were the victims of a violent anti-gay attack Saturday on a small island off Key West, Fla.

Jeffrey Pellissier

In an interview with the Miami Herald, Pellissier, an insurance agent, said he and Miller, a leadership coach, had rented a boat and an inflatable dinghy. They anchored the boat and used the dinghy to paddle to Wisteria Island to walk the beach and snorkel.

As they were getting ready to leave the island, Pellissier said a small skiff occupied by a man and a woman came forward. According to a police report, the occupants of the skiff, Christopher Thomas John Yarema, 43, and Stephanie Lynn Burnham, 35, yelled at Pellissier and Miller. “Hey Mr. Speedo [gay slur], get the [expletive] off our island!” Burnham threatened to kill them if they didn’t leave quickly.

Keith Miller

Burnham punched Pellissier in the face and hit him in the head with an oar. Yarema attempted to stab Pellissier twice but missed him, instead stabbing the dinghy.

Pellissier and Miller were able to get into the dinghy and travel back to their boat and radio for help.

Yarema and Burnham were arrested and taken to the Stock Island Detention Center where both were being held this afternoon on $15,000 bonds. According to the Herald, “Burnham was listed as a “stage performer” who is homeless. Yarema is listed as a fisherman and roofer with a Caroline Street address in Key West.”

WEHOville has reached out to Pellissier for information about the incident and will update the story when he responds.

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
dove night
dove night
1 year ago

homophobia in Florida ! with its somewhat conservative political climate, it is not a surprise, If anyone who is gay or a minority who visits florida or live there ,have to be cautious

Woody McBreairty
Woody McBreairty
4 years ago

For those who think & say that we live in a “post gay era” & that “we are safe & can live anywhere”, should rethink their thoughts. We don’t & we can’t.

Larry Block
Larry Block
4 years ago

Hey Jeff – hope your ok. Keith too.

4 years ago


Would love your thoughts, please comment.x